What is compassion fatigue?

Compassion fatigue is the emotional and physical cost of repeatedly helping people who are suffering. It is common in roles built around other people's distress: nurses, doctors, social workers, therapists, and increasingly HR teams and customer support staff. The traumatologist Charles Figley described it in a 2002 paper in the Journal of Clinical Psychology as a form of caregiver burnout, shaped by "the costs of caring, empathy, and emotional investment in helping the suffering".

Today it is usually understood as having two parts. The most widely used measure in this field, the Professional Quality of Life scale (ProQOL) developed by Beth Hudnall Stamm, treats burnout and secondary traumatic stress as the two components of compassion fatigue, and a systematic review by Cocker and Joss (2016) describes it in the same way, as the convergence of secondary traumatic stress and cumulative burnout.

I am a clinical psychologist, and I find this two-part view the most practical, because the two parts respond to different kinds of help. We already have a guide to the personal side of compassion fatigue; this article treats it as a workplace issue: who is at risk, how to measure it, and what organisations can change.

How is compassion fatigue different from burnout and secondary traumatic stress?

The terms overlap and are often used interchangeably. The ProQOL descriptions make the differences clear.

AspectBurnoutSecondary traumatic stressCompassion fatigue
What it isHopelessness and difficulty doing the job effectivelyStress from work-related, secondary exposure to other people's traumatic eventsThe combination of the two in helping roles
Where it comes fromOften a very high workload or an unsupportive work environmentHearing about, seeing or working with others' traumaSustained exposure to suffering plus strained working conditions
How it startsUsually gradualUsually rapid, often linked to a particular eventCan build slowly or follow a specific case
Typical signsFeeling that your efforts make no difference, exhaustionFear, poor sleep, intrusive images, avoiding remindersA mix of both

The ProQOL also measures a positive dimension, compassion satisfaction: the pleasure of being able to help others well. Helping work is not only a risk, and protecting its meaning is part of prevention. Note too that burnout can happen in any job, while secondary traumatic stress requires exposure to other people's trauma; our guide to burnout at work covers the six areas of worklife behind burnout.

Who is most at risk of compassion fatigue at work?

Most of the research comes from healthcare. In a systematic review of 71 studies, Cavanagh and colleagues (Nursing Ethics, 2020) found compassion fatigue "across all practitioner groups studied", but also that prevalence was highly variable and its links to factors such as years of experience or specialty were inconsistent. A meta-analysis of 79 studies covering 28,509 nurses in 11 countries, by Xie and colleagues (International Journal of Nursing Studies, 2021), found moderate average levels, with the highest compassion fatigue among nurses working in intensive care, and levels rising between 2010 and 2019.

Social work is the other well-studied group. In a study of US social workers, Bride (Social Work, 2007) found that those in direct practice were highly likely to be exposed to trauma secondhand, that many had at least some symptoms of secondary traumatic stress, and that "a significant minority" may meet the diagnostic criteria for PTSD.

Outside health and social care, the evidence is much thinner. In my clinical work, though, I see the same pattern in people whose job is to absorb other people's distress:

  • HR professionals who handle grievances, redundancies, bereavements and misconduct cases, often without anyone to debrief with.
  • Customer support teams who spend the day with angry, frightened or grieving customers and are measured on speed rather than recovery.
  • People managers who become the informal first responder for their team's crises.

These roles rarely have the supervision structures that clinical professions have built over decades.

What are the signs of compassion fatigue at work?

Signs usually show up in how someone relates to the people they help and how they feel outside work.

  • Dreading certain cases, clients or calls, and feeling relieved when they cancel.
  • Feeling numb or detached from the people you are supposed to help, then guilty about it.
  • Irritability, cynicism or gallows humour that no longer feels like a release.
  • Intrusive thoughts or images about a particular case, or trouble sleeping after difficult conversations.
  • Exhaustion that a weekend does not fix, and a sense that nothing you do makes a difference.
  • Withdrawal from colleagues, or reluctance to talk about work at all.

None of these is a diagnosis, but when several persist for weeks, they call for a conversation, not for trying harder.

How is compassion fatigue measured?

The ProQOL is the standard tool. The current general version, ProQOL 5, has 30 items about the last 30 days and gives separate scores for compassion satisfaction, burnout and secondary traumatic stress. The Center for Victims of Torture has maintained the measure since 2016 and also publishes a version for health workers, the ProQOL Health.

Its terms of use are unusually open. According to the measure itself, it "may be freely copied as long as (i) the author is credited, (ii) no changes are made, and (iii) that it is not sold". Organisations may substitute more specific words for "helper", such as nurse or support agent, without asking for permission, and the ProQOL FAQ says there is no charge for using it.

Two cautions apply. First, ProQOL's own guidance says it is "a screening and research tool that provides information but does not yield a diagnosis". Second, the publisher advises that continuous scores are more informative than cut-offs. For employers, that means using it anonymously and at team level, tracking change over time, and never using individual scores in performance decisions.

What helps individuals?

Personal strategies cannot compensate for an impossible caseload, but they do matter. Figley's 2002 model points to limiting compassion stress, dealing with traumatic memories, managing caseloads more effectively, and learning to separate from work emotionally and physically so that people feel renewed. In practice, that usually means:

  • Closing the day. A short ritual that marks the end of work, especially after a difficult case.
  • Talking it through. Regular, structured supervision or peer support, not just a chat when things go wrong.
  • Noticing which part dominates. Exhaustion and hopelessness point towards workload and conditions; intrusive images and fear point towards trauma-informed professional support.
  • Protecting what gives meaning. Keeping some contact with the parts of the work that bring compassion satisfaction.

Our existing guide to compassion fatigue covers personal recovery in more depth.

What can organisations do about compassion fatigue?

The research base is young. Cocker and Joss's 2016 systematic review of interventions for healthcare, emergency and community service workers identified only 13 relevant studies, most of them with nurses; seven reported a significant improvement in burnout or secondary traumatic stress after the intervention. We know organisations matter, but not yet which programme works best.

There are promising signals. Schwartz Rounds are organisation-wide forums in which staff discuss the emotional and ethical side of their work. In an evaluation in England funded by the National Institute for Health Research, Maben and colleagues (2018) found that the proportion of staff with poor psychological wellbeing fell from 25% to 12% among Rounds attenders, compared with 37% to 34% among non-attenders. The results relied on self-report, and fewer regular attenders were recruited than planned, but they suggest that structured, shared reflection can help.

Practical steps for employers:

  • Treat exposure as a workload issue. Spread the most distressing cases, calls or grievances across the team instead of letting them land on the same people.
  • Build in supervision and debriefing. Clinical roles have this; HR and support teams usually do not.
  • Create shared spaces for reflection, such as Rounds-style forums or regular team debriefs.
  • Measure, anonymously. Use the ProQOL at team level and act on what it shows. Dzeny's free anonymous team mental health audit adds a view of burnout and anxiety by department.
  • Train managers. WHO's guidance on mental health at work recommends manager training so supervisors can recognise distress and understand how job stressors affect mental health.
  • Make support easy to reach, including your EAP, and be clear that using it carries no stigma.

Where does Dzeny fit?

Dzeny is an AI-based mental wellbeing app. It does not replace supervision, trauma-informed therapy or changes to caseloads and working conditions. What it can do is give someone in a helping role a private place to offload after a hard day, notice patterns in their stress, sleep and mood, and practise evidence-informed techniques for switching off. For people who spend all day holding other people's distress, having somewhere to put their own can make it easier to recognise when they need more support.

The bottom line

Compassion fatigue is the cost of caring at work, made up of burnout and secondary traumatic stress. It is well documented in healthcare and social work and, in my experience, increasingly visible in HR and customer support. Individuals can protect themselves with boundaries, supervision and recovery, but organisations decide how exposure is shared, whether people have space to reflect and whether anyone measures the cost. Those levers matter most.